Plain-language guides to business cybersecurity and risk assessment

Employee Monitoring and Privacy: Where the Limits Lie

employee monitoring privacy laws

Whether you run a team or sit on one, employee monitoring privacy laws mostly turn on notice. In the US, employers can usually monitor company systems, but New York, Connecticut and Delaware require prior notice, as of 2022 legal alerts.

This guide sits within our wider coverage of business data privacy, and it focuses on where workplace monitoring runs into legal limits.

Item Value
New York monitoring-notice law signed Nov. 8, 2021
New York law took effect May 7, 2022
New York civil penalties (maximum) $500 first offense, $1,000 second, $3,000 for each later offense
Connecticut civil penalty range $500 to $3,000
Delaware civil penalty $100 per violation

The figures come from Holland & Knight’s May 2022 alert and Morrison Foerster’s November 2021 client alert. Laws and penalties can change, so check the source before you rely on them.

What the federal baseline allows

At the federal level, the Electronic Communications Privacy Act (ECPA) governs the monitoring of electronic communications at work. According to Venable’s August 31, 2022 overview, it generally prohibits intentional interception of employees’ oral, wire and electronic communications. Two big exceptions apply: a legitimate business reason, or the employee’s consent.

The same overview says employers are not prohibited from monitoring activity where the employee had no reasonable expectation of privacy. That covers company-owned devices and networks, such as company-issued laptops, email and internet access. Reading messages sent through and stored on the employer’s network is therefore generally not barred by the ECPA.

In practice, WilmerHale’s June 28, 2022 alert notes that US law has, for the most part, been very supportive of aggressive employee monitoring, as long as employees are told about it. That is why notice sits at the center of most rules. The ECPA is only the floor, and states can add stricter limits.

Common monitoring techniques that fall under these rules include:

  • Keystroke monitoring and idle time tracking
  • Video and audio surveillance
  • GPS systems
  • Fingerprint scanning

Venable’s overview also points out that the workplace now often includes an employee’s home, so remote staff are not outside these rules.

employee monitoring privacy laws Office workstation
A man wearing headphones works at a desktop computer with a colleague seated behind him.

Which states require notice of monitoring?

As of Holland & Knight’s May 2022 alert, three states have statutes that require employers to give notice of electronic monitoring. Their approaches differ in who must be told, when, and whether the employee has to acknowledge it.

  • New York: notice upon hiring, with written or electronic acknowledgment, plus a notice in a conspicuous place that all employees can view.
  • Connecticut: prior written notice of the types of monitoring, posted conspicuously. The notice is not specific to new hires and does not require affirmative acknowledgment.
  • Delaware: employers choose between a notice each time the employee accesses employer-provided systems, or a one-time written or electronic notice with acknowledgment.

Connecticut defines electronic monitoring broadly. It covers information collected on the employer’s premises about employees’ activities or communications by any means other than direct observation, according to Morrison Foerster.

Connecticut also allows monitoring without prior notice when an employer has reasonable grounds to believe employees are violating the law, violating the legal rights of the employer or others, or creating a hostile workplace. Penalties in Connecticut range from $500 to $3,000, while Delaware allows $100 for each violation, per Holland & Knight.

How New York’s notice law works

New York’s law amends the Civil Rights Law and applies to all private employers in the state, regardless of size or entity type. It covers monitoring of phone calls, email and internet access or usage. The attorney general enforces it, and the law does not provide a private right of action, according to Holland & Knight.

For an employer, the requirements boil down to these steps:

  1. Give each new hire written or electronic notice upon hire.
  2. Get the employee’s written or electronic acknowledgment.
  3. Post the notice in a conspicuous place that employees can readily view.
  4. State that communications and internet use may be subject to monitoring at any and all times and by any lawful means.

Morrison Foerster notes an exception for activity that manages the type or volume of email, phone or internet use, is not targeted at a particular employee, and is performed solely for systems administration or protection. Holland & Knight warns this may leave gray areas, because one tool can serve several purposes. A tool that protects the network but also flags one person’s browsing may not fit the exception.

Penalties are modest per violation but escalate: a maximum of $500 for a first offense, $1,000 for a second and $3,000 for each later one.

Other privacy rules that can limit monitoring

Notice statutes are not the only limit. Venable says a state with a two-party consent rule may prohibit recording employee phone calls altogether, even after notice. Several state constitutions, including those of California, Florida, Louisiana and South Carolina, expressly guarantee a right to privacy that may extend to private employees. Unionized workplaces may face further limits under the National Labor Relations Act or a collective bargaining agreement.

Data privacy laws matter too. In its June 2022 alert, WilmerHale said California employers covered by the CCPA must tell employees which categories of personal information they collect and why. It added that the CPRA would bring employment data fully under the law, giving employees the ability to access, correct, delete and restrict use of their personal information. Check the current state of that law before acting on it.

Monitoring data often counts as personal data, so it helps to understand what is personally identifiable information before you collect any. Collecting only what a stated purpose needs is the idea behind data minimization, and it lowers both legal and breach risk.

A practical checklist for a monitoring policy

Morrison Foerster suggests that a company wanting a uniform approach across its US locations should give prior written notice to, and get an acknowledgment from, all relevant employees, including new hires. It adds that the notice should cover every type of electronic monitoring in use, not only phone, email and internet. This is general education, not legal advice.

  1. List every monitoring tool in use and the purpose each one serves.
  2. Write a policy describing the types of monitoring and employees’ expectation of privacy in company systems and equipment.
  3. Distribute the policy, post it conspicuously and collect signed acknowledgments.
  4. Check state rules on recording calls before you monitor phone conversations.
  5. Apply what monitoring reveals consistently, because Venable warns that uneven handling of misconduct can invite discrimination claims.
  6. Review the policy whenever you add a new tool or enter a new state.

Notice and acknowledgment are the common thread. Other obligations can arise from wiretap laws, National Labor Relations Board rulings and common law, depending on the facts, per Morrison Foerster.

Frequently asked questions

Can my employer read my work email?

Show answer

Generally yes on company systems, as of Venable’s August 2022 overview. The ECPA does not bar employers from reading messages sent through and stored on their own network. Some states require that you be told first.

Does New York require employees to acknowledge monitoring?

Show answer

Yes, as of Holland & Knight’s May 2022 alert. Employers must give notice upon hiring with written or electronic acknowledgment, and post it conspicuously.

Can an employee sue under New York’s monitoring law?

Show answer

Not directly. The alert says the law does not provide a private right of action, and the attorney general enforces it through civil penalties. Other claims, such as invasion of privacy under a state constitution or statute, are separate matters.

Do these rules apply to remote workers?

Show answer

Venable notes that the workplace often includes an employee’s home. Monitoring of company devices and accounts used remotely generally raises the same notice questions.