Plain-language guides to business cybersecurity and risk assessment

Rolling Out Multi-Factor Authentication at Work

multi-factor authentication for business

Setting up multi-factor authentication for business can feel like one more job on a crowded list. You can start small: require a second proof of identity on email, file sharing and remote access first, then widen from there.

This guide is part of our wider look at business cybersecurity, where MFA sits next to the other basic controls.

Item Value
Authenticators needed for MFA Two or more different authenticators
Where CISA wants MFA applied All users and all services
Strongest form (October 2022) Phishing-resistant MFA, such as FIDO/WebAuthn
Best interim options for small and medium businesses App- or token-based OTP, or push with number matching
Weakest form SMS or voice codes, a last resort
Recommended rollout style In phases, starting with high-value targets

These figures come from CISA’s October 2022 fact sheet and Cybersecurity Dive’s November 2022 coverage. Guidance can change, so check the source before you rely on them.

What MFA does for a business

CISA defines MFA as a control that requires a user to present two or more different authenticators to log in: something you know, something you have, or something you are. If a password is stolen, the attacker still cannot get in without the second factor.

That extra layer stops some common techniques, such as password spraying. In its October 2022 fact sheet, CISA said it has consistently urged organizations to use MFA for all users and all services, including email, file sharing and financial account access (CISA).

MFA is not a complete shield, though. As The HIPAA Journal reported in November 2022, some forms can be circumvented, and phishing kits with reverse proxies can steal login credentials, MFA codes and session cookies. That is why the type of MFA you choose matters.

Which multi-factor authentication methods are strongest?

Not all MFA is equal. CISA’s October 2022 fact sheet ranks the common forms from strongest to weakest by how well they resist phishing, push bombing, SS7 exploitation and SIM swap attacks:

  1. Phishing-resistant MFA: FIDO/WebAuthn authentication or PKI-based authentication.
  2. App-based or token-based codes, and push with number matching: OTP codes generated by an app or a token, or a mobile push that asks the user to enter a number.
  3. Plain push notifications: approval prompts without number matching.
  4. SMS or voice codes: a code sent to a phone.

As of CISA’s October 2022 fact sheet, the only widely available phishing-resistant option is FIDO/WebAuthn. It is supported by major browsers, operating systems and smartphones, and can take the form of a physical USB token or a component built into a laptop or phone (Cybersecurity Dive). PKI-based MFA is less widely available but may suit larger organizations.

If you cannot move to phishing-resistant MFA yet, CISA says app- or token-based OTP or mobile push with number matching are the best options for small and medium-size businesses. Number matching means the user must enter numbers from the identity platform into the app before approving, which helps defeat push bombing.

Why text-message codes rank last

SMS and voice codes are vulnerable to phishing, SS7 and SIM swap attacks. In a SIM swap, attackers convince a carrier to move the victim’s phone number to a SIM card they control. CISA says this form of MFA should only be a last resort, although it can serve as a temporary step while you move to something stronger.

Where to start: a phased rollout

You do not have to switch everything on at once. CISA notes that larger organizations will find it difficult and impractical to train, enroll and support all users at the same moment, so it recommends phases (Cybersecurity Dive).

A workable order, based on that guidance:

  1. Take stock of your IT systems and work out which ones support MFA.
  2. Begin with the resources of most value that attackers often target: email systems, file servers and remote access systems that reach corporate data.
  3. Cover high-value people next: system administrators, executives, and staff with extra privileges or access to personnel records, such as attorneys and HR.
  4. Favor services that already support the stronger methods, such as hosted mail platforms, before tackling harder products.
  5. Widen to all users and all services once the early groups are running smoothly.

The reason to put administrators early is plain. In CISA’s words, if an attacker compromises a system administrator’s account, they may be able to access any system and any data in the organization.

multi-factor authentication for business Phone interaction
A gloved hand holds a smartphone while another hand points toward its screen.

MFA is one control among several. The guide to ransomware protection for business shows how it fits alongside the others.

Handling systems that do not support MFA

Some older or specialist applications will not offer MFA. CISA recommends that you identify them and plan either to upgrade them or to migrate to systems that do support MFA.

There are practical workarounds:

  • MFA for business applications can often be added through enterprise identity and single sign-on (SSO) systems.
  • Where that is not directly possible, technology exists to connect a wide range of legacy systems to modern MFA and SSO.
  • Any system that still cannot support MFA should be escalated as a risk to senior leadership.

The last point matters because it turns a quiet technical gap into a decision someone is accountable for.

Bringing employees along

Expect some pushback. Cybersecurity Dive’s November 2022 report says some employees find MFA a nuisance, so security leaders should explain the risks and how stronger MFA improves defenses.

Tell staff what an attack looks like. In push bombing, attackers send a stream of prompts until the user presses “Accept”. In a common phishing technique, a fake login page collects the username, password and the 6-digit code from an authenticator app. Both are good reasons to teach people to report unexpected prompts rather than approve them.

Decide in advance who receives those reports and what happens next. Your incident response plan is the natural place to write that down.

Frequently asked questions

Is any MFA better than none?

Show answer

Yes. CISA’s October 2022 fact sheet says any form of MFA is better than no MFA and reduces an organization’s attack surface, while phishing-resistant MFA remains the gold standard to work toward.

Are text-message codes acceptable?

Show answer

Only as a last resort or a temporary step. As of CISA’s October 2022 fact sheet, SMS and voice codes are vulnerable to phishing, SS7 and SIM swap attacks.

Do you need hardware security keys?

Show answer

Not necessarily. FIDO/WebAuthn can use physical tokens, but it can also be built into laptops and phones. If you cannot adopt it yet, CISA points small and medium-size businesses to app- or token-based OTP or push with number matching.

What is push bombing?

Show answer

It is an attack where a threat actor floods a user with push notifications until the user presses “Accept”. Number matching helps prevent it by requiring the user to enter a number from the identity platform.